Skip to content
Broken UFO Project BROKEN UFO
Avalon Harbor and Catalina Casino, Avalon, Santa Catalina Island (California)
SOURCE PUBLIC EXP-01952 OPEN Document SECTOR: DECLASSIFIED FILES

Kirkpatrick says some cases were resolved: what the PURSUE papers show

The former AARO chief says Pentagon leadership ordered cases that had been resolved to be published as “unresolved.” One record and four Catalina reports, checked against the portal.

OPERATIONAL SUMMARY

Kirkpatrick, former AARO chief, tells Fox News (11/1/2026) that many PURSUE cases were resolved and published as open on orders from leadership. Checked against the portal's data sheet and four Catalina reports.

1
What is claimedThat there were solutions and they were withdrawn on orders from Pentagon leadership.
2
What evidence existsOne record (PR038) with “Resolved as an Aircraft” in one field; three cards from 1949 to 1955 with conclusions (meteor, Jupiter, insufficient data) under the title “unresolved.”
3
What doubts remain openNo named case; no date or author of the order; his reports to Congress cannot be verified; PR038 may be a leftover; CSV copy of 10/28.
8 min
1,597 words
Washington, D.C. / Santa Catalina Island, California
V3 · Plausible Source: Department of War (PURSUE) and Fox News
Start reading
MISSION DEBRIEF EXP-01952

Executive summary of the case file. Everything essential before you dig deeper.

Fact sheet

Code EXP-01952
Source material PUBLIC
Status OPEN
Type Document
Location Washington, D.C. / Santa Catalina Island, California
Opening date 02/11/2026
Last review 02/11/2026

OSINT - Traceability

Verification: V3 · Plausible Source: Official Entity: Department of War (PURSUE) and Fox News
Opening date 02/11/2026
Status OPEN
DECLASSIFIEDREF: PURSUE · PR038 · D177 · D178 · D179 · D181
ClaimKirkpatrick, former AARO chief, says many cases were resolved and were published as “unresolved”
WhereFox News interview, 11/1/2026
Evidencethe portal's data sheet (478 records) and four Catalina reports
Resultone video title contradicts its own record; three cards from 1949 to 1955 conclude something else
Missinga single named case that he says was resolved

On Sunday, November 1, 2026, Fox News published an interview with Sean Kirkpatrick, who headed the Pentagon office dedicated to unidentified anomalous phenomena (AARO). The headline says he disputes the FBI black triangle case (the case file on that case).

What matters comes further down, in a sentence that affects the whole PURSUE series: according to him, many of those cases were resolved, and Pentagon leadership ordered the resolution removed and the cases published as open.

It is an accusation against the series and should be treated as one. It is not accepted because of who makes it, nor dismissed for the same reason. It can be checked against the record. The portal publishes a data sheet with all the records and the original PDFs.

This text separates what Kirkpatrick said, what the papers say and what remains unchecked, which is quite a lot.

What he said, word for word

Wehner, the author of the piece, quotes these sentences from Kirkpatrick. They are in quotation marks because they are his and can be read in the Fox article; I have not heard the recording.

Many of these cases, we did resolve, and I even briefed several of them to Congress with the answers.

Sean Kirkpatrick, according to Fox News

Pentagon leadership had told AARO to remove all of the resolution language and put these cases out as unresolved.

Sean Kirkpatrick, according to Fox News

He adds that letting “the people make up their own mind” is, in his words, “the absolute worst thing that you could do.”

He also defines his terms: “unresolved” usually means there is no data or the data is insufficient, so that “you can’t conclude one way or the other”; “unidentified” means the object can be characterized and there is data to back that up, but it is not known what it is.

Of what he analyzed, he says, nothing fits an extraterrestrial hypothesis, and of the release: “there’s nothing new.”

A Department of War official, speaking on condition of anonymity, told Fox that they offer no comment or assessment of the files as a whole or of any one in particular, “so that the American people can make up their own minds.”

The department also confirmed that the images accompanying the FBI report on the triangular object are illustrations.

Something is missing from all this. The article does not name a single case that Kirkpatrick says was resolved. It gives no date for the order, nor who gave it, nor which congressional sessions heard those answers. An accusation with no service window and no stamp is an accusation. It may be true. It is not yet a fact.

What “unresolved” means according to the man who used it

Before opening anything, the words need fixing, because the accusation depends on them. Kirkpatrick distinguishes two things. “Unresolved” would be a case without enough data to analyze it. “Unidentified” would be a case with data that allows the object to be described, without knowing what it is. And a resolved case is one with an explanation backed by that data.

“Unresolved,” according to Kirkpatrick
There is no data or it is insufficient to analyze the case. According to him, “you can’t conclude one way or the other.”
VS
“Unidentified,” according to Kirkpatrick
The object can be seen and characterized, there is data backing that description, but it is not known what it is.
ℹ
A tension in his definition (my own reading)
A consequence follows from his own definition that he does not develop in the article. If “unresolved” means “there is no data,” a case concluded as a meteor or a planet does not fit there: it has data and it has an answer. It tells us what to look for: records with a written conclusion that the portal presents as open.

The PURSUE series does not use the word rigorously either. In the data sheet, 75 video rows carry “Unresolved” in the title; among the PDFs, 15 of 298 (12 on October 12, three more with the seventh release: D177, D178 and D181).

Applying it in bulk may be haste or may be a criterion; the sheet does not say which.

How it was checked

The Department of War’s PURSUE portal offers its catalog as a CSV. I worked with the copies I saved on October 12, 25 and 28 (478 rows in the last two, 28 of them from the seventh release, of 10/23), because on November 1 the server returned a 403 on the download.

The three copies agree on everything reported here, and their hash is recorded in the dossier. If the portal changed after the 28th, this comparison does not know it.

The test has two parts. First: search the data sheet for any record carrying resolution language. Second: open the PDFs of the seventh release whose title says “Unresolved” and read what the person who filled them in at the time concluded.

If Kirkpatrick is right, the first search should turn up traces of erasure and the second, closed cases with an open label.

First search: a record that contradicts itself

Of the 134 video records, 26 carry “Unresolved” in the video title column and 107 have it empty. There is one exception. Record DOW-UAP-PR038, published on May 8, 2026, is titled “Unresolved UAP Report, Middle East, 2013,” but its “Video Title” field reads “Resolved as an Aircraft, Middle East 2013.”

It is the only one in the sheet with resolution language in a title. No description in the three copies contains “resolved” without the “un” in front.

Record title (Title column)
DOW-UAP-PR038, Unresolved UAP Report, Middle East, 2013
Redaction: yes · DVIDS video 1006088 · published 5/8/2026
VS
Video title (Video Title column)
Resolved as an Aircraft, Middle East 2013
The DVIDS page reads “Unresolved”; the copy on a third-party tracker keeps “Resolved”

The official description is the kind that shies away from the word. U.S. Central Command sent a 1-minute, 46-second infrared video recorded in 2013; whoever submitted it provided no description; and the reader is asked not to see any analytical judgment in the text. Incident, date: “N/A.” Two readings are possible.

A leftover that slipped through a cleanup, or a text field nobody reviewed.

That is where what I can state ends. That the field says “Resolved as an Aircraft” proves that at some point someone wrote that label for that video. It does not prove who, when, or that the order Kirkpatrick speaks of exists.

Nor do I know whether the title changed after October 12, the first copy I have, which already carries it. One row does not make a policy. It makes a question for AARO.

Second search: four Catalina papers

The seventh release (October 23) brought four PDFs about Santa Catalina Island, off Los Angeles. Three are titled “Unresolved UAP Report”; the fourth, an air intelligence report, has that text in the file name but not in the portal title.

I read them in the text layer and on the image. They are cards and letters from the investigations of the Air Force of the day, not AARO reports.

EV-01Reliability: HIGH
D177, 3/15/1955, Avalon. A man sees an orange object, the size of a nickel at arm’s length, falling vertically for two seconds. On the conclusion box of the project 10073 form, “Was Astronomical” is checked and, typed beside it, “Meteor.” Comment: “Probable meteor.” The portal title: “Unresolved UAP Report.”
EV-02Reliability: HIGH
D178, 11/16/1953, military source at Long Beach base. Ten minutes of observation. Conclusion: “Astronomical (JUPITER).” The form notes that the object’s movement does not match the winds aloft, that astronomers at an observatory evaluated it, and that Jupiter was 45 degrees to the west. The portal title: “Unresolved UAP Report.”
EV-03Reliability: HIGH
D181, 4/28/1949, letter to Kenneth Arnold. An Avalon resident tells Arnold about six objects. The accompanying card reads “INSUFFICIENT DATA FOR EVALUATION.” The portal title: “Unresolved UAP Report.”

At first sight, this supports Kirkpatrick on the small point. Two of the three cases titled “unresolved” had a conclusion from the Air Force itself: a probable meteor and Jupiter. Whoever filed them believed there was an answer. The portal title says the opposite.

The third, from 1949, supports Kirkpatrick’s definition: “insufficient data” is exactly what he says “unresolved” means, and there the title is correct.

The fourth, D179, is an August 1952 report from the 807th Air Base Group at March base, about three Boy Scouts at Camp Fox who saw a silent, silvery object. It is the case Fox cites.

Its evaluation box says “None,” and the portal description says the officer made no attempt to establish the reliability of the source: “probably meager at best.”

⚠
What these papers do not demonstrate
“Unresolved” is today’s AARO label; the cards from the 1950s are judgments of the Project Blue Book of the time. That a 1955 paper says “meteor” and the portal titles it “unresolved” is consistent with Kirkpatrick’s thesis, but does not prove that anyone received an order. It may be a different titling criterion (“what is published is an unresolved report”) or an oversight.

What the papers add about Catalina

There are details in the four records that give an idea of what kind of “unresolved” this is. The 1955 card describes a round object, orange to red, very bright, which fell vertically for two seconds.

The portal description adds that the officer who prepared the form wrote “possibly astronomical” and that the case did not warrant further investigation. For the Air Force of 1955, a closed case.

The 1953 one is more stubborn. The form’s comment says the movement did not match the winds aloft, and even so the conclusion checked is Jupiter. The form notes that discrepancy and the checked conclusion remains Jupiter.

If one had to look for a case where a conclusion leaves a residue of doubt, this is a better candidate than the 1955 one.

The 1949 one is something else: a letter from a private citizen to a famous author, with a card that merely says there is not enough information. It is what Kirkpatrick would call “unresolved” by the book.

That the same batch contains side by side a case nobody could evaluate and another dispatched as a meteor, under the same label, is what justifies the complaint about the titling, with an order or without one.

What I think, marked as my own reading

My own reading, undocumented: the portal uses “Unresolved” as a drawer. It holds what has no data (1949), what had an explanation nobody defended again (1953, 1955) and what is recorded without evaluation (1952).

On that reading, Kirkpatrick’s sentence about the difference between unresolved and unidentified is reasonable, and it is the portal itself that ignores it. No order is needed for that. A title made in a hurry is enough.

That reading holds for the four Catalina records and does not hold for PR038, where someone did write “Resolved” and someone later put “Unresolved” in the field next to it. But one row is not to be generalized.

To support an order from the top, more rows would have to be seen (two other cases in the series, the helicopter orbs and the report on the birds, are in this site’s archive), edit dates and a document. None of that is published.

ℹ
The debt on the other side
The Department of War can shelter behind its line that the public should form its own opinion. But an archive that comes out without comment and with labels that do not always match the content of the page leaves the reader without a reliable compass. Kirkpatrick calls it the worst thing one can do. On the labels, the papers give him some reason.

What remains open

  • A single named case that Kirkpatrick says was resolved, with a date, and the congressional sessions at which he reported it.
  • When and by whom the PR038 video title was changed (the October 12 copy already carries it).
  • The history of the portal’s data sheet, which is not public.
  • Which specific cases are the ones that, according to him, AARO resolved and that were published without that resolution.
1949-04-28

D181: letter to Kenneth Arnold

Six objects over Avalon; card reads “insufficient data”

Source ↗
1952-08-28

D179: AIIR report

Three Boy Scouts, silent silvery object

Source ↗
1953-11-16

D178: sighting at Long Beach

Conclusion on the form: Jupiter

Source ↗
1955-03-15

D177: orange ball over Avalon

Conclusion on the form: meteor

Source ↗
2026-05-08

PR038 published

“Resolved as an Aircraft” in one field, “Unresolved” in the title

Source ↗
2026-10-23

PURSUE seventh release

The four Catalina reports arrive

Source ↗
2026-11-01

Kirkpatrick on Fox News

Says leadership ordered the solutions removed

Source ↗

What can be checked is simple: whether AARO or the Department of War publishes the list of cases that Kirkpatrick says he reported to Congress, or whether the title of PR038 changes on the portal. Meanwhile, the accusation sits on the table without papers.

OSINT – Source traceability

File completeness75/75
View breakdown
  • +20 Primary source linked
  • +5 Official domain
  • +15 Type: oficial
  • +10 Identified entity
  • +10 Source date
  • +5 Editorial notes
  • +5 Verification level assigned
  • +5 Documented corroboration
Source type Official
Entity / Origin Department of War (PURSUE) and Fox News
Verification level V3 · Plausible
Timeline
Published source
Published on BUFO
Primary source www.war.gov
OSINT editorial notes

V3: verifiable official documents, but the central accusation is a statement with no case or date. Own reading, marked: “Unresolved” as a drawer; PR038 as a leftover. It is not claimed that an order existed.

Sources
[01] Fox News, Greg Wehner (11/1/2026) www.foxnews.com
[03] Portal data sheet (CSV) www.war.gov
[04] DOW-UAP-D177 (1955) www.war.gov
[05] DOW-UAP-D178 (1953) www.war.gov
[06] DOW-UAP-D179 (1952) www.war.gov
[07] DOW-UAP-D181 (1949) www.war.gov
[08] DVIDS, video 1006088 (PR038) www.dvidshub.net
[09] PURSUE UFO Tracker (third party), PR038 pursueufotracker.com

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

What exactly did Kirkpatrick say?
According to Fox News (11/1/2026), that many cases were resolved, that he briefed Congress on several of them with the answers, and that Pentagon leadership told AARO to remove the resolution language and publish them as unresolved. He names no case.
Is any case in PURSUE published as resolved?
Only one: in the portal's data sheet, the “Video Title” field of PR038 reads “Resolved as an Aircraft, Middle East 2013,” while the record's title reads “Unresolved.” It is the only row with resolution language in a title.
What do the Catalina reports conclude?
The 1955 one checks “Was Astronomical” and “Meteor”; the 1953 one, Jupiter; the 1949 one, insufficient data. Three of them are titled “Unresolved” on the portal; the 1952 one, whose evaluation is illegible in the copy, is titled as an air intelligence report.
Does this prove there was an order to hide solutions?
No. It is consistent with the accusation, but also with a different titling criterion or an oversight. Dates, names and documents are missing.
Channel active
Newsletter
SEC:BUFO
Email newsletter

Get a briefing when something moves in the dark.

New case files, declassified documents, recommended reading and signs of anomalous activity. One email when it matters. Zero noise. Zero spam.

No mass mailings
Unsubscribe anytime
OSINT-friendly
Activate subscription
Alternate channel
Follow via RSS
Unit note

We don't sell your email, we don't run campaigns, we don't chase you with cookies. We only send what deserves a place in your archive.

Stable signal No ads One-click unsubscribe