Of all the figures this subject has produced, Kenneth Arnold is the most unfairly treated. He is remembered as the man who saw the first flying saucers, and it turns out he didn’t see saucers, didn’t say saucers, and ended up not believing in saucers. Three mistakes in a single sentence. Not bad for someone whom history cast as a prophet without consulting him.
An ordinary man with a working airplane
Kenneth Albert Arnold was born on March 29, 1915, in Sebeka, Minnesota. He was an Eagle Scout, played high school football at a good level, and spent a short time at the University of Minnesota in the mid-1930s. In 1940 he founded a company in Boise, Idaho, called Great Western Fire Control Supply, which sold and installed fire suppression systems. The kind of business that runs on invoices and customer visits.
He flew because his sales territory was enormous and mountainous, and because he liked it. He had a CallAir A-2, a small, sturdy airplane built for rough strips and open country, not an aero club toy. He also helped with search and rescue work in the Northwest, which explains why on June 24, 1947, he left his route between Chehalis and Yakima to comb the foothills of Mount Rainier: a reward of five thousand dollars had been offered for locating a crashed Marine C-46 in the area.
The misunderstanding that followed him for forty years
What Arnold described on June 25, 1947, in the newsroom of the East Oregonian in Pendleton was a movement: those nine things moved with a weaving motion, like a saucer skipped low across water. A simile about trajectory. Within forty-eight hours, the American press had turned the simile into a geometric shape and coined flying saucer. It is the documented birth of UFO iconography, and it is told in detail in his case file.
Arnold spent the rest of his life correcting this, without success. In 1950, in front of Edward R. Murrow on CBS, he explained again that they flew in the manner of a saucer, not that they were saucers. It made no difference. Once a whole country has learned a word, it doesn’t unlearn it because the person concerned politely asks.
His actual description of the shapes was considerably stranger and more interesting: convex profiles, something like a half moon, one object different from the other eight, almost the look of a bat’s wing. None of that fit a headline. The headline won.
Maury Island: the mistake that cost him dearly
That same summer, Arnold got involved in the murky Maury Island affair, near Tacoma: slag supposedly fallen from the sky, elusive witnesses, and a pulp magazine editor, Ray Palmer, financing the trip. The investigation ended in tragedy: Lieutenant Frank Brown and Captain William Davidson, two Army Air Forces intelligence officers who had come to look into the matter, died on August 1, 1947, when their B-25 crashed. Edward Ruppelt, who years later would head Project Blue Book, called the whole episode a hoax.
Arnold was not a swindler and no serious person has ever claimed he was. It was something more common and more human: an honest man whom sudden fame drew into company that did him no good. With Palmer he co-wrote The Coming of the Saucers in 1952, which sold reasonably well and did nothing for his reputation.
Arnold said the objects flew the way a saucer would if you skipped it low across the water.
The end: politics, sky jellyfish and silence
In 1962 he won the Republican nomination for lieutenant governor of Idaho and lost the election. He carried on with his company and his flying. And, over the years, he drifted away from the spacecraft hypothesis: he ended up proposing that those things were not machines but living organisms of the upper atmosphere, something like jellyfish of the sky. The idea earned him the scorn of most of the ufology scene, which by then had its own orthodoxy and admitted no heretics.
He died on January 16, 1984, in Bellevue, Washington, at the age of sixty-eight, of colorectal cancer. He had spent almost four decades being introduced everywhere as the flying saucer man, a label he hadn’t chosen, that didn’t describe what he said, and that he had stopped believing in.
There is a lesson in that, and it concerns how little a witness controls his own testimony once it enters the machine, not UFOs. Arnold told what he saw with a homely comparison, the kind you use in a bar so people will understand you. And the comparison slipped out of his hands, grew up, moved out, and ended up founding a minor religion to which he was no longer invited.