In the Alps of Haute-Provence there are villages hanging above the valleys, where the wind comes down from the peaks smelling of cold stone and cut hay, and where a boy who cannot run with the others has plenty of time to watch the sky. In one of them, Saint-Vincent-les-Forts, Aimé Michel was born in 1919.
Polio left him, as a child, with a small body and a mind that would not sit still. After the war he made his living in French public broadcasting, and in 1954, the year half of France leaned out of the window, he became the most influential chronicler of that wave. So much for the landscape. Now, the file.
What can be verified, first
Michel was not a contactee or a seller of revelations. He was a writer with scientific curiosity and a voracious reader who, when the wave of autumn 1954 arrived, did what almost no one in France did at the time: he gathered the clippings from the regional press and the published testimonies, and sorted them by date, time and place. An archivist’s work, not a visionary’s. That was his best contribution, and also the source of his worst mistake.
His first book, Lueurs sur les soucoupes volantes, came out in 1954. The second, Mystérieux objets célestes (1958), is the important one: in it he proposed that the sightings of a single day in France were not scattered at random, but lined up in straight lines across the map. He called it orthoteny. The English translation, Flying Saucers and the Straight-Line Mystery, made him famous outside France. The context of that autumn is in the case file on the 1954 French wave.
If a phenomenon starts drawing straight lines across the map of France, it does so with cartographic intent. Or so it seemed in 1958.
What it is said to have proved
The most famous of his lines joined Bayonne and Vichy, and the christening came out with a bureaucratic acronym: BAVIC. According to Michel, several sightings of September 24, 1954, hundreds of kilometers apart, fell on that line. To a reader in 1958 it looked like the signature of something with a flight plan. A mirage does not draw straight lines hundreds of kilometers long.
The idea had enormous appeal because it looked like a data point and not an anecdote: geometry, map, ruler. Other researchers set about looking for alignments in other waves and in other countries. And that, precisely, is where it began to fall apart.
What it can be, with no Martians required
The problem is statistical, and it can be understood on a napkin. When you mark many points on a map, alignments appear by pure chance, more of them the more points there are and the wider the line you allow. Later analyses, including those by researchers close to Michel, concluded that the lines of orthoteny did not exceed what chance produces on its own. The signature was the pencil’s, not the phenomenon’s.
There is a second problem, a more mundane one. The locations and times of 1954 came mostly from the regional press, with precision of the “on the outskirts of” and “past midnight” kind. With coordinates like that, a line several kilometers wide swallows almost anything. It is like drawing a line between two cattle fairs and being surprised that it passes through three bars.
For an alignment to mean anything, three things are needed that orthoteny did not have:
- precise coordinates for each point, not “on the outskirts of”;
- a line width fixed before looking at the map, not after;
- a comparison of the result with the alignments that turn up by chance with the same number of points.
What he can be faulted for
Here at Broken UFO we hand out no medals. Michel can be faulted for turning an intuition into a system before testing it, and for the fact that for years orthoteny was cited as a discovery when it was no more than an unvalidated hypothesis. He can also be faulted because his prose, brilliant and persuasive, pushed the idea more than the data did. But one thing must be granted him, and it is not minor: he worked with dates, times and places, which is the only thing that allows someone else to contradict him.
Why it matters
Michel matters for what he left sown. He wrote in the magazine Planète, of Louis Pauwels and Jacques Bergier, which did so much to popularize the unusual in France in the sixties, and for years he corresponded and talked with a young Jacques Vallée, who has acknowledged him as a mentor. The French interest in studying the phenomenon with method, which would end up with an office of its own in GEPAN, counts him among its precursors.
And there remains the lesson of orthoteny, which is still useful: a pattern that appears on a map must be compared with the one that would appear by chance before it is given a name. Vallée later went down his own road, told in Jacques Vallée’s turn.
He died in 1992. He left straight lines that no longer mean anything and a habit that is still useful: noting the exact time.