Men in Black: How an Archetype Gets Manufactured in Forty-Five Years
The only official document that exists on the MIB says they are not from the Air Force and that anyone who poses as one commits a federal crime. Everything else was written by a traveling movie salesman from West Virginia who was having the time of his life.
The Man in Black archetype can be reconstructed documentarily from 1947 to 1997. It starts with the acknowledged Maury Island fraud, consolidates with the abrupt shutdown of Albert K. Bender's club in 1953 and takes its definitive form in the book Gray Barker published in 1956. When Bender finally told his version, in 1962, it turned out to be a theosophical fantasy that bore no resemblance to the myth. Barker's private correspondence, preserved in a public library in West Virginia, and the published testimony of a collaborator establish that he knowingly fabricated fiction. The only official document in the whole chain is a 1967 Air Force letter warning of impersonators.
Executive summary of the case file. Everything essential before you dig deeper.
Fact sheet
OSINT - Traceability
We are going to perform an autopsy. The corpse is an archetype: the man in the black suit, blank face, dark car, who turns up at your door after you have seen something and politely suggests you keep quiet. He is in the movies, in comics, in TV series and in everyone’s head. And he can be rebuilt piece by piece, with dates, from his origin to his box-office debut.
In the entire documentary chain there is exactly one official letter. And it says the opposite of what people believe.
The timeline of the archetype
The literary precedent
Fred Lee Crisman publishes a letter in Amazing Stories magazine, in the context of the so-called Shaver mystery, saying that he and a companion came out of a cave shooting and that he has two scars of twenty-some centimeters. Harper's cites it in September as an example of a crank letter. Remember that name.
Maury Island
Harold A. Dahl says he saw six doughnut-shaped objects over Puget Sound, three days before Kenneth Arnold's sighting.
The first man in black
Dahl describes a tall, heavyset man in a black suit, driving a new 1947 Buick, who invited him to breakfast, told him the details of the sighting before Dahl had made them public and gave him a veiled warning about his family.
The two officers
Captain William L. Davidson and Lieutenant Frank M. Brown die when their B-25 crashes on the way back from investigating the case. The legend now has martyrs.
The club is born
Albert K. Bender founds the International Flying Saucer Bureau in the attic of his home in Bridgeport, Connecticut, decorated with horror motifs. It reached some six hundred members.
World Contact Day
Bender organizes a collective attempt at telepathic contact at six in the evening, Eastern time.
The visit
Bender places here the visit of three men dressed in black who communicated telepathically and ordered him to stop publishing.
The shutdown
Last issue of Space Review. Bender announces that the flying saucer mystery is no longer a mystery, that the source is known but the information is being withheld by order of a higher authority, and advises those working on the subject to be very cautious. Then he closes the club.
The myth is born
Gray Barker publishes They Knew Too Much About Flying Saucers. It is the book that invents the Men in Black as we know them.
The witness speaks
Bender publishes Flying Saucers and the Three Men, edited by Barker. And he tells something completely different from what his editor had written.
The statement
Colonel George P. Freeman, spokesman for Project Blue Book, states that men in Air Force uniforms are silencing witnesses and that they do not belong to the Air Force. The source is not a document: it is a magazine article by John Keel published in October.
The only paper
Letter from Lieutenant General Hewitt T. Wheless, Assistant Vice Chief of Staff of the USAF, to all commands. Subject: impersonation of Air Force officers.
Point Pleasant
The Mothman wave in West Virginia, culminating in the collapse of the Silver Bridge on December 15, 1967, with 46 dead.
The theology
John A. Keel publishes UFOs: Operation Trojan Horse. The MIB stop being government agents and become manifestations of a non-human intelligence.
The comic
Aircel Comics publishes the first issue of The Men in Black, by Lowell Cunningham and Sandy Carruthers. Three issues that year.
The box office
Men in Black, by Barry Sonnenfeld, is released. Budget of $90 million. Worldwide gross of more than $589 million. The archetype now belongs to everyone.
Maury Island: the founding fraud
The first man in black of the canon does not appear in 1953. He appears on June 22, 1947, and his case file is a fraud acknowledged almost unanimously, even among believers.
Harold A. Dahl, who presented himself as a harbor patrolman, said that the day before he had seen six doughnut-shaped objects over Maury Island, in Puget Sound, and that one of them began to expel what looked like thousands of newspapers: hot slag that supposedly killed his dog and injured his fifteen-year-old son. The next day, the man in the black suit and the 1947 Buick.
The FBI concluded that Dahl and his partner Fred Crisman admitted it was a hoax. The slag was smelter waste. And here comes the detail that seals the case for me: Crisman was already a published fabulist a year earlier. His 1946 letter to Amazing Stories, the one with the cave and the machine gun, had appeared in Ray Palmer’s publishing ecosystem. The same Ray Palmer who in 1947 hired Kenneth Arnold to investigate the case of his own contributors.
A coda of the kind nobody could invent: on November 21, 1968, New Orleans District Attorney Jim Garrison summoned Crisman before the grand jury in his investigation into the Kennedy assassination. He questioned him and let him go. Some people pass through twentieth-century history like a draft of air.
Bender: the witness who told a different story
Albert Kenneth Bender (Duryea, Pennsylvania, 1921 – Los Angeles, 2016) set up, in 1952, in the attic of his home in Bridgeport, the first civilian UFO club with international reach. It published a newsletter, organized days of collective telepathic contact and had some six hundred members.
In October 1953 he shut it all down at once, with a last issue in which he more or less said that the flying saucer mystery was no longer a mystery, that the source was known but the information was being withheld by order of a higher authority, and that he advised those working on the subject to be very cautious.
And now the part almost nobody has read, because the book is hard to find and a good deal harder to defend. In 1962, Bender finally published his full version, Flying Saucers and the Three Men, edited, prefaced and appended with an epilogue by Gray Barker. And what does it say?
- Three men in black with glowing eyes who communicated by telepathy.
- A trip by astral projection to an underground alien base beneath Antarctica.
- A transfer to another planet, Kazik, whose inhabitants went naked, were bisexual, implanted thoughts in him and rubbed him with an ointment.
- And some extraterrestrials who were on Earth extracting a substance from seawater and who would leave in 1960.
There lies the key to this whole case file, and it is a structural marvel: the bureaucratic myth is not in the original testimony. The gray, governmental, threatening agent in the impeccable suit was never described by the witness. His editor built him, six years earlier, and he survived intact when the witness himself contradicted him in writing. The unofficial version preceded and buried the protagonist’s version.
A well-built myth does not need the witness to confirm it. It is enough that the witness arrives late.
Gray Barker, or the man who knew he was lying
Gray Roscoe Barker (1925-1984), of West Virginia, published They Knew Too Much About Flying Saucers in April 1956. Two hundred and fifty-six pages that begin with the Flatwoods monster and end with the Bender case. It is the founding text. Everything you now associate with the MIB is there.
Barker also set up his own publishing house and published half of American ufology over three decades, including Bender’s book. That is: he created the myth, published the myth’s witness and sold both.
And here is where the case file stops being a suspicion and becomes a proven case, because a first-rate documentary source exists.
The journalist John C. Sherwood, who was a teenage collaborator of Barker’s and later worked twenty-eight years in the press, told it in Skeptical Inquirer in May-June 1998. And he told it from the inside, because he took part.
In the late sixties, Sherwood and Barker fabricated a false story together. Sherwood, signing as a certain Dr. Richard H. Pratt, claimed to have been silenced by the men in black after discovering that UFOs were time-travel vehicles. It was published as real fact in Ray Palmer’s magazine Flying Saucers and in Barker’s own publications. Barker’s reaction after publication, according to Sherwood, was: obviously, the fans swallowed it whole.
In his private correspondence Barker referred to his own paranormal books as his crazy books. His colleague James W. Moseley stated that Barker took practically all of ufology as a joke. His sister said he wrote mostly for money.
Sherwood adds a nuance that has to be respected, because it is honest: there was a grain of truth in the Government discouraging interest in UFOs. Barker, he says, merely embellished the facts enormously.
The only official document, and the irony it contains
We reach the end of the documentary chain. Of the entire MIB corpus (books, magazines, testimonies, films) there is a single official paper, and it deserves a slow reading.
Impersonations of Air Force Officers
Document · March 1, 1967
Read it again. The only official document that exists on the Men in Black says they are not from the Air Force, that the Air Force does not know who they are, and orders its own people to alert the military police if they show up. Impersonating an officer is a federal crime.
That is: the State does not confirm the MIB. It reports that someone is imitating them. Which is exactly the opposite of what the myth needs in order to work, and that is why the myth has never cited this letter.
Two warnings of rigor, given here even though they cost us a headline. First: the copies of that letter in circulation are photocopies of photocopies, almost illegible. It is widely reproduced in the literature, but I have not located a legible institutional scan, so I treat it as an attested document and do not pull long phrases from it. Second: the famous statement by Colonel George P. Freeman, Blue Book spokesman, saying that men with impressive credentials were silencing witnesses and that they were not from the Air Force, is not a document. It comes from an article John A. Keel published in SAGA magazine in October 1967. There is no press release, no record, no letter signed by Freeman.
And while we are at it, another one that circulates a lot and that you should not repeat: there is no 1967 memorandum signed by Hector Quintanilla on this subject. If you have read it, you have read it wrong, and whoever wrote it did not check either.
Keel, the theological conversion, and then Hollywood
In 1970, John A. Keel published UFOs: Operation Trojan Horse and gave the myth its last layer. Keel broke with the nuts-and-bolts extraterrestrial hypothesis and argued that the encounters reproduced patterns from ancient folklore and religious apparitions. The Men in Black stopped being officials and became manifestations of a non-human intelligence. He called them, literally, demonic supernaturals.
Keel was also the one who merged the MIB with the Mothman wave at Point Pleasant, West Virginia, between November 1966 and December 1967. That story ended with the collapse of the Silver Bridge and forty-six dead, a real and tragic event that the narrative absorbed without blinking.
And from there to the cash register. In January 1990, Aircel Comics published the first issue of The Men in Black, by Lowell Cunningham with art by Sandy Carruthers. Three issues that year, three more the next. The original comic is considerably darker and more brutal than what came after. Aircel was absorbed by Malibu and Malibu by Marvel in 1994: that is how the rights ended up where they did.
On July 2, 1997, Barry Sonnenfeld’s film was released. A ninety-million budget. More than five hundred and eighty-nine million in worldwide gross. An Oscar for makeup. And the archetype, definitively, beyond the reach of any rebuttal.
45
from an attic in Bridgeport to the worldwide box office
1
and it says they are NOT from the Air Force
What is true, which also needs saying
I am not leaving without the part that is uncomfortable for skeptics, because this site does not sell comfort to anyone.
That the myth is manufactured does not mean that strange things did not happen. The Wheless letter exists precisely because someone was approaching witnesses and taking away material. The Heflin case is real and the original photographs disappeared. That whoever did it was not a Government agent does not make it any less unsettling: they may have been unscrupulous private investigators, swindlers, unidentified counterintelligence people or simply cranks in suits. We do not know. And the Air Force itself acknowledged in 1967 that it did not know.
Add the context of the period, which is documented on this very site: the Robertson Panel and the Blue Book machinery included among their recommendations defusing public interest in the subject. That is, there was a policy of discouragement. There was no need to invent it. Barker inflated it into an order from telepathic mobsters, which is something else.
If you are interested in the craft of making myths out of paper, go on to the UMMO case, which is the Spanish equivalent and considerably more sophisticated. And to the faces of Bélmez, where the myth was made not by an editor but by an entire country looking the other way.
OSINT – Source traceability
No 1967 memorandum is attributed to Hector Quintanilla because no such document has been located. Colonel George P. Freeman's statement is expressly recorded as coming from a magazine article, not from an official source. The Wheless letter is treated as an attested and widely reproduced document, but of poor copy quality, so no verbatim phrases are extracted from it.