Ufology has spent seventy years producing two kinds of character: the one who tells what he saw and the one who tells what he was told. Leslie Kean belongs to a third category, far less populated and far more uncomfortable for everyone: the one who asks for the papers.
She has no testimony of her own. She has not seen anything. She makes no claims about the origin of anything. What she does is what an investigative reporter covering courts or public contracts does: identify which document ought to exist, request it through formal channels, appeal when told no, and sue when the appeal fails.
Applied to this field, that method is almost revolutionary. And it worked.
Kecksburg: the school
On January 31, 2003, Kean filed a Freedom of Information Act request with NASA for the documentation on an event that took place in Kecksburg, Pennsylvania, on December 9, 1965: the fireball that half a continent saw and that an entire town maintains landed in its woods.
NASA did what every administration does: it stalled. Kean sued. The case reached federal judge Emmet Sullivan of the District of Columbia court, who is not known for tolerating agencies that play dumb. In March 2007, the agency agreed to carry out an exhaustive search for the records and to pay $50,000 in costs and fees.
What turned up afterward was disappointing: NASA maintained that the relevant documentation had been lost in the 1980s. But the journalistic result was the precedent, not the content. It was established that in this area you can litigate, you can win, and agencies pay.
50.000 $
paid by NASA in 2007
4
from the request to the resolution
2010: the book that changed the tone of the debate
In 2010 she published UFOs: Generals, Pilots, and Government Officials Go on the Record, which was a bestseller in the United States and carried a foreword by John Podesta, former White House chief of staff. The book’s approach is simple and enormously effective: it offers no anonymous witnesses. It offers air force generals, commercial and military pilots, and public officials, all identified and all speaking under their full names.
Among the voices in the volume are names such as former Arizona governor Fife Symington and Nick Pope, who handled the subject at the British Ministry of Defence. The book’s thesis is much more modest than a visit, and therefore harder to rebut: that there is a residue of unexplained military and aviation cases, that institutions know it, and that refusing to study it is a political decision, not a scientific one.
Kean’s trick was never getting revelations. It was getting people with something to lose to speak with their names attached. That is slower, less spectacular and far harder to disprove.
December 16, 2017
That is the date that split the subject into a before and an after. That day, The New York Times published a report signed by Helene Cooper, Ralph Blumenthal and Leslie Kean revealing the existence of a Department of Defense program dedicated to the study of unidentified aerial phenomena.
What mattered was not the content, which was relatively modest: a small program with limited funding inside a colossal defense budget. What mattered was where it was published. After that front page, a congressman, a pilot or an admiral could talk about the subject without being taken for a lunatic. The social cost of the question dropped all at once.
Everything that has come since (reports to Congress, dedicated Pentagon offices, public hearings) descends directly from that front page. And that front page descends, in a straight line, from the method Kean learned by fighting NASA over some papers about a 1965 fireball.
The criticisms, which also exist
It would be dishonest to paint her as a figure beyond objection. There are objections, and they are of two kinds.
The first is methodological: she is faulted for a favorable selection of cases, that is, presenting the unexplained residue without giving equal space to the vast majority of cases that are explained. It is a fair criticism. Anyone who has read the declassified Spanish files knows that the real proportion is overwhelmingly conventional, and that context does not always appear in her work with the weight it deserves.
The second concerns her later subjects: Kean has also published on phenomena of a different nature, including the survival of consciousness, a terrain where the documentary method that made her valuable simply cannot be applied. Each reader will judge. Here at Broken UFO we stay with the part that can be audited: the requests, the appeals, the ruling and the front page.
- Kecksburg 1965, where it all began.
- The public hearing on UAP, where it ended up.
- George Knapp, the other journalist in the American case file.