The AARO Historical Report: 63 Pages, Seven Invited Journalists and a Volume II That Never Arrives
In March 2024 the Pentagon released the report that was supposed to close eighty years of UAP history. An office signed it, a director who had already left wrote it, it was presented to seven hand-picked journalists, and it never mentions the country's most famous case.
On March 8, 2024, the All-domain Anomaly Resolution Office published Volume I of its report on the U.S. Government's historical involvement with anomalous phenomena, ordered by the fiscal year 2023 defense act. It runs 63 pages covering 1945 to 2023 and concludes there is no evidence of possession or reverse engineering of non-human technology. It was written by the outgoing director, who had left the office on December 1, 2023, and presented by his acting successor in a session restricted to about seven journalists. The announced Volume II remains unpublished.
Executive summary of the case file. Everything essential before you dig deeper.
Fact sheet
OSINT - Traceability
Intelligence Network
March 2024. The All-domain Anomaly Resolution Office, AARO to its friends, publishes the report it had been promising for two years: the complete historical review of the U.S. Government’s involvement with anomalous phenomena, from 1945 to the present.
Sixty-three pages. Volume I. And silence ever since.
I’m not here to tell you whether the report lies. I’m here to tell you what can be verified about how it was made, who wrote it, who was shown it first and what is missing from it. Because in this trade, what a document leaves out often says more than its paragraphs.
The file sheet, first things first
A note on legal plumbing, because it circulates wrongly and it matters to me. The report was not ordered by the law that created the office. The office was born with section 1683 of the fiscal year 2022 defense act. The mandate for this particular report came later, in the fiscal year 2023 defense act, and not through one but through two separate routes within the same statute. If you wonder why a Congress puts the same obligation through two doors: because it didn’t trust it to get in through one.
What the report says
Plainly, its main conclusions:
- There is no evidence that any U.S. Government agency has possessed or reverse-engineered technology of non-human origin.
- Roswell is explained by the Project MOGUL balloon and, as for the alleged bodies, by the anthropomorphic dummies dropped in Air Force tests in the 1950s. Watch the program name: the one associated with those dummies is High Dive, not Excelsior, which is a different one. It’s a common mistake.
- Much of the material that fed cover-up beliefs comes from real secret programs misidentified by witnesses who knew they were seeing something odd and could not know what it was.
- There was a proposal called Kona Blue, put to the Department of Homeland Security by former members of the Defense Intelligence Agency program, which was never approved. In other words: people did propose a program to recover exotic material. And they were told no.
That last point is the most interesting and the one that made the fewest headlines, because it fits neither cage. It doesn’t prove there are craft. It proves that inside the apparatus there were people convinced that there were, with enough weight to draft a formal proposal. That is a file with letterhead, not some crank on a forum.
A proposal being rejected doesn’t erase it. It makes it proof that someone with access believed enough to ask for a budget.
Who wrote it, and when he left
This stretch is pure Astro-speak, and it’s the kind that gets overlooked because it looks like human resources.
The office is born
AARO is established, successor to the UAP task force, under the mandate of the fiscal year 2022 defense act.
The mandate
The fiscal year 2023 defense act orders the historical report, and does so through two separate routes within the same text.
The announcement
Deputy Secretary of Defense Kathleen Hicks announces the departure of Sean Kirkpatrick, AARO's first director.
Last day
Kirkpatrick leaves the office. The report he wrote has not yet been published.
The Grusch memo
An internal Department document, later released under FOIA, details at least eleven attempts by AARO to interview David Grusch between June 2023 and January 2024.
The select briefing
Timothy Phillips, acting director, presents the report in an in-person, invitation-only session before about seven journalists. Outlets specializing in the subject are left out. The Washington Post, Politico and The New York Times had received advance copies about forty-eight hours earlier.
Publication
Volume I is released. 63 pages.
Source ↗Immediate reaction
Luis Elizondo publicly calls it intentionally dishonest, inaccurate and dangerously misleading. Congressman Tim Burchett sums it up: the people running the cover-up say they find no cover-up.
The technical critique
Researcher Robert Powell publishes a scathing review, which he himself stresses is in a personal, not institutional, capacity.
Under oath
Retired Rear Admiral Tim Gallaudet tells the House Oversight Committee that his meeting with AARO was an influence operation lasting hours to convince him of the report's validity.
No Volume II
AARO's publications index still lists only Volume 1, from 2024.
Let’s say it clearly: the report was written by a director who was no longer in the office when it was published. His acting successor presented it, but publicly attributed authorship to his predecessor and mentioned that about a hundred days of technical editing and legal review followed.
Christopher Mellon, former Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Intelligence, asked the uncomfortable question out loud: did Kirkpatrick rush to get the report out before leaving, perhaps to make sure his successor could not review or reverse some of its conclusions? I have no way to answer that. But it is a legitimate question, and it was asked by someone who knows how that house works from the inside.
Seven journalists
And here is the detail that tells me more than any conclusion in the report.
Think about it for a second. A report whose declared purpose is to show that there is no opacity is presented with the communication technique used to control a narrative: advance copies to friendly outlets, a small room, and none of the journalists who have been on the subject for years and who are the only ones qualified to ask the awkward technical question.
The content is not necessarily false, but the procedure contradicts the thesis. And when the procedure contradicts the thesis, people stop reading the content. That is exactly what happened.
The absences
The best thing about a document is what isn’t in it. And here there is a notable list.
- The USS Nimitz does not appear. Not once. Not even “Tic Tac.” The most famous case in the modern history of the subject, the one that holds up half the public conversation, is not mentioned in the historical report.
- Neither are the three Navy videos. No FLIR, no GIMBAL, no GO FAST. The material that the Department of Defense itself officially released in 2020 does not figure in its own historical review.
- Anonymized names. The report avoids naming several central actors in the story it tells, including the contractor and the ranch that were the setting of the Defense Intelligence Agency program.
It can be argued that a report on government programs need not analyze individual incidents. It’s a reasonable argument and it has to be conceded. But then don’t call it a historical review of the subject, because the citizen who reads that title expects to find inside what everyone associates with the topic. And it isn’t there.
The criticisms, ranked by quality
Because they are not all worth the same, and mixing them is doing the report a favor.
The good one: specific factual errors
Researcher Robert Powell published the next day a review with verifiable findings. And they are the kind that sting:
- The report dates Kenneth Arnold’s sighting, the founding case of all modern ufology, to June 23, 1947. The correct date is the 24th.
- It calls Project BEAR a program whose contract name was Project STORK, and never mentions that name. To be fair: the report itself explains that BEAR was the informal name Captain Ruppelt gave to the contract with the Battelle Memorial Institute, so the office was aware of the fact and simply preferred the nickname to the file name in a document that aspires to be the historical reference. The delicious part: “BEAR” was a false name that Edward Ruppelt deliberately put in his 1956 book. In other words, the Pentagon’s official office copied the pseudonym from a popular book of seventy years ago instead of going to the archive.
- The report also contains a typo that is already a classic: it places Harry Reid as a senator from New Mexico. He was from Nevada.
- And Powell’s overall assessment: there is a tendency in the document to select the data that support its position and leave out those that could challenge it.
The political one: legitimate but not probative
Luis Elizondo called it, on the day of publication, intentionally dishonest, inaccurate and dangerously misleading. Congressman Tim Burchett summed it up with the efficiency of someone who has run campaigns: the people running the cover-up say they find no cover-up. A self-fulfilling prophecy, he added.
It’s a good line. It is not proof. And it’s wise not to confuse the two, even if he is entirely right to point to the structural problem: a Department of Defense office auditing the Department of Defense. That doesn’t invalidate its work, but it is exactly the kind of arrangement no financial audit in the world would accept.
The one that collapses: the unheard witnesses
And here I have to say something the other side won’t like, but it’s what is in the file.
I don’t particularly like the result, but the document is the document. On this specific point, the file favors AARO.
What does stand established on the critical side is that several heavyweight outside experts, Jacques Vallée among them, were not consulted, according to Mellon. And that the acting director refused to say whom they had interviewed: as a practice, he said, we don’t reveal who came to talk to us. Which is a legitimate answer in intelligence and utterly useless in an exercise in historical transparency.
The most serious: under oath
On November 13, 2024, at a House Oversight Committee hearing, retired Rear Admiral Tim Gallaudet, an oceanographer and former acting NOAA administrator, testified that his meeting with AARO was an influence operation lasting several hours, intended to convince him of the validity of the historical report, which he described as highly flawed and riddled with errors. He added that they tried to make him doubt the Tic Tac incident, going as far as suggesting it might have been American technology.
That is a serious accusation made by a flag officer under oath before Congress. I don’t take it as proven: it is testimony, not a document. But it is on the record and cannot be ignored.
And Volume II, when?
Good question. The report is called Volume I. That implies a Volume II. It was announced, it was expected, and to this day the office’s own publications index still lists a single entry under that heading.
2
according to the report's own title
1
two and a half years later
A report that numbers itself and then has no sequel is, administratively speaking, a broken promise in writing. And here at Broken UFO, broken promises in writing are worth their weight in gold, because they are the only ones you can claim on.
Add one last piece, with bitter humor: among the report’s assertions was that no specific nondisclosure agreements exist on this subject. A year later, the case known as Yankee Blue, uncovered by the American business press, called that assertion into question.
A report that says nothing is hidden and is presented to seven hand-picked journalists doesn’t have a content problem. It has a form problem. And in this trade, form is content.
My reading, in Astro-speak
I think a good part of the report’s content is probably correct. I think Roswell was a balloon, I think many witnesses saw real secret programs and didn’t know what they were, and I think there is no public evidence of reverse engineering of anything.
And I also think this report was destined to fail as an instrument of trust for reasons that have nothing to do with whether it tells the truth. A departing director wrote it. Another, who didn’t sign it, presented it. It was shown first to three outlets and then to seven invitees. It contains verifiable errors on the founding case of the discipline. It omits the best-known incident in the country. And it promised a second volume that has not arrived.
None of these things proves there are Martians in a hangar. Taken together they prove something else, smaller and more certain: that the State still doesn’t know how to communicate a credible denial. And that until it learns, each of its reports will feed exactly what it means to dismantle.
Continue with the document itself, the 2021 ODNI report that paved the way, the July 2023 hearing that provoked it, and our tracking of the 2026 NDAA. And if you want to see the same pattern fifty-five years earlier, there is the Condon Report.
OSINT – Source traceability
Several widely repeated claims that could not be verified are deliberately omitted: that Karl Nell or Jay Stratton stated they were not interviewed, the statements attributed to Congresswoman Anna Paulina Luna about the later briefing, and any assessment attributed to Senator Marco Rubio. Robert Powell's critical review is recorded as his personal opinion, which is how he himself presents it: there is no institutional refutation from the Scientific Coalition for UAP Studies. Christopher Mellon's letter was incorporated into the congressional record by Representative Nancy Mace.