Skip to content
Broken UFO Project BROKEN UFO
Flight operations on the deck of the aircraft carrier USS Nimitz in the Pacific, August 2004.
SOURCE PUBLIC EXP-00498 OPEN Close encounter SECTOR: UAP AND BROKEN SKIES

The Nimitz Tic Tac: Ninety Seconds of Video and Twenty Years of an Empty Case File

November 2004, off Baja California. An Aegis cruiser has been seeing things for two weeks, a squadron commander goes down to take a look, and nobody, absolutely nobody, files a report. The strange part isn't the object. The strange part is the archive.

OPERATIONAL SUMMARY

In November 2004, during the USS Nimitz carrier strike group's training cycle off Baja California, the cruiser USS Princeton detected anomalous contacts on its Aegis system for days. On November 14, Commander David Fravor, commanding officer of squadron VFA-41, was sent to one of those contacts and described a white Tic Tac-shaped object over a patch of churned water. Another crew shortly afterward recorded the video known as FLIR1. No investigation was opened and no primary radar data has been preserved. The Navy acknowledged the video's authenticity in 2019 and the Department of Defense released it in 2020.

1
What is claimedThat an object some twelve to fourteen meters long, with no wings, rotors or control surfaces, maneuvered in ways impossible for known technology, reacted to the fighter's approach and reappeared on the USS Princeton's radar about sixty miles away in under a minute.
2
What evidence existsA written, sworn statement to the U.S. Congress; an infrared video authenticated by the Navy and officially released by the Department of Defense; converging testimony from several crew members and radar operators; and a thirteen-page 2009 report that the Pentagon refuses to authenticate. No primary radar data is publicly available.
3
What doubts remain openThere are no records. The altitude and speed figures in circulation come from different sources that contradict each other. Technical analysis of the video suggests that a good part of the apparent motion is produced by the camera itself. Neither ODNI nor AARO has examined the case in writing, and AARO omits it entirely from its 2024 historical report.
9 min
1,773 words
Off the coast of California and the Baja California peninsula, Pacific Ocean
V3 · Plausible Source: U.S. Navy / Department of Defense; U.S. House of Representatives
Start reading
MISSION DEBRIEF EXP-00498

Executive summary of the case file. Everything essential before you dig deeper.

Fact sheet

Code EXP-00498
Source material PUBLIC
Status OPEN
Type Close encounter
Incident date 14/11/2004
Location Off the coast of California and the Baja California peninsula, Pacific Ocean
Opening date 24/04/2026
Last review 24/04/2026

OSINT - Traceability

Verification: V3 · Plausible Source: Official Entity: U.S. Navy / Department of Defense; U.S. House of Representatives
Opening date 24/04/2026
Incident date 14/11/2004
Status OPEN

I’m here to tell you about the most cited UAP case of the 21st century, and I’m going to do it backwards from the way it has always been told to you. I won’t start with the object. I’ll start with the paperwork, which is where the body is always buried.

November 2004. The carrier strike group of the USS Nimitz (CVN-68) is running its pre-deployment training cycle off the coast of California and the Baja California peninsula. With the group sails the cruiser USS Princeton (CG-59), which carries the Aegis combat system and the AN/SPY-1B radar. And that radar, according to the sworn testimony of the man who was told about it over the radio, had been logging for two weeks things that dropped from above 80,000 feet to 20,000, stayed for hours and climbed back up.

Two weeks. A first-line naval combat system. And of all that, today, twenty years later, there is publicly not a single primary radar data point. That is the case file. The rest is literature.

What can be verified, first

“A friend told me” doesn’t count here. This is what can be sustained with a document in front of you:

  • A written, sworn statement exists from David Fravor to the House Oversight Committee, filed for the July 26, 2023 hearing. In it he details the episode himself: he was commander of squadron VFA-41, attached to Carrier Air Wing Eleven, aboard the Nimitz.
  • The U.S. Navy officially acknowledged the video. In September 2019, a spokesman for the Deputy Chief of Naval Operations for Information Warfare, Joseph Gradisher, stated that the Navy designates the objects in those videos as unidentified aerial phenomena.
  • The Department of Defense formally released them on April 27, 2020, describing one as recorded in November 2004 and stating that the phenomena remain categorized as unidentified.
  • The time window of the 2021 ODNI preliminary assessment begins in November 2004. Watch this one, because it’s where half the internet gets it wrong.
⚠
A MUCH-REPEATED LIE
The June 2021 ODNI report does NOT mention the Nimitz. Not once. It names no individual case. The fact that its dataset starts in November 2004 allows the reasonable inference that the case is inside it, but inference is not confirmation. No one in the U.S. Government has published a document that says: the Nimitz Tic Tac is an unidentified phenomenon, and here is the data.

The chronology, where the trick shows

2004-11-10

The tracks begin

According to Petty Officer Kevin Day, an air intercept controller on the Princeton, the anomalous contacts began showing up on Aegis around the night of November 10. Fravor, for his part, speaks of two weeks earlier. The two versions don't quite match.

2004-11-14

The encounter

Lieutenant Colonel Douglas Kurth (VMFA-232) is the first one sent to the contact, in a single-seat F/A-18C: he sees the disturbance on the water, sees no object. Fravor's section arrives afterward.

2004-11-14

The video

Back aboard, Fravor tells a crew that was about to launch. Lt. Chad Underwood records with the ATFLIR pod the sequence now known as FLIR1.

2004-11

The silence

No investigation is opened. Fravor states under oath that there was no report of any kind, beyond the routine debriefing in the ship's intelligence center.

2009

The unofficial investigation

Jay Stratton contacts Fravor. Out of that comes the so-called Executive Report, a thirteen-page document with no cover page, no date and no classification markings.

2017-12-16

The New York Times

Helene Cooper, Ralph Blumenthal and Leslie Kean publish the story that brings the case and the AATIP program into public view.

Source ↗
2018-05-18

The report leaks

George Knapp, of KLAS's I-Team in Las Vegas, publishes the 2009 Executive Report. The Pentagon responds that it cannot confirm its authenticity.

2019-09-17

The Navy acknowledges it

Joseph Gradisher confirms that the objects in the videos are designated as unidentified aerial phenomena.

2020-04-27

Formal declassification

The Department of Defense releases the three videos.

2021-05-16

The second pilot appears

Alex Dietrich identifies herself publicly on 60 Minutes. Until then, the second crew member was believed to be someone else.

2023-07-26

Under oath

Fravor testifies before the House National Security Subcommittee.

Source ↗
2024-03

AARO doesn't touch it

AARO's Historical Record Report does not mention the Nimitz. Zero occurrences. Its former director Sean Kirkpatrick tells The Guardian that there is not enough data and that nothing was kept because there was no retention policy.

Who was there (with name and post, which is how things are done)

PRIOR DETECTIONS

2weeks

according to Fravor's sworn statement

YEARS UNTIL OFFICIAL RELEASE

15

from November 2004 to April 27, 2020

PUBLICREF: BUFO-NIMITZ-2004
CarrierUSS Nimitz (CVN-68)
Air wingCarrier Air Wing Eleven (CVW-11)
Control cruiserUSS Princeton (CG-59), Aegis system, AN/SPY-1B radar
Group submarineUSS Louisville (SSN-724)
Witness's squadronVFA-41 Black Aces, F/A-18F Super Hornet
Simulated adversary in the exerciseVMFA-232 (Marines)
Pilot 1Cdr. David Fravor, commanding officer of VFA-41
Pilot 2Lt. Alex Dietrich (retired as Lt. Cdr.)
ATFLIR operator who records FLIR1Lt. Chad Underwood
First aircraft over the siteLt. Col. Douglas Kurth (VMFA-232), F/A-18C
Radar controlPetty Officer Kevin Day, Princeton

About those coordinates: they are indicative, and I give them reluctantly. An exact point in degrees and minutes circulates online that appears in no primary document, official or leaked. What is on record is that the patrol point was some forty miles south of the carrier and that the press placed the episode about a hundred miles from San Diego. With that you can build a map. With the other you build a legend.

A note of the kind that doesn’t make it into the documentaries. For years it was taken for granted that the episode’s second crew member was Lieutenant Commander Jim Slaight, because the original 2017 story implied it. When Alex Dietrich identified herself on television in 2021, the reconstruction had to be redone: Slaight was in the back seat, with Fravor. And the systems officer in Dietrich’s aircraft remains publicly unidentified today. Twenty years. The most famous case in the world. And for one of the four protagonists, we don’t know the name.

And another one, this one even better: the first aircraft sent to the contact was not Fravor’s. It was that of Lieutenant Colonel Douglas Kurth, who was flying alone in an F/A-18C on a functional check flight. Kurth saw the disturbance on the water. He saw no object. That detail drops out of almost every account because it spoils the movie.

What is told: Fravor’s account

His written version, the one he gave to Congress, says this. They were going to run a two-versus-two air-to-air exercise with the VMFA-232 Marines playing the bad guys. The Princeton cancels the exercise and gives them a real tasking. The patrol point was about forty miles south of the ship. The controller calls merge plot at 20,000 feet: the friendly echo and the contact are already in the same resolution cell.

Perfect weather: clear sky, light wind, calm sea with no whitecaps. Against that blue stands out a patch of white water, churned water. Above it, a small white object shaped like a Tic Tac, its long axis north-south. No rotors. No rotor wash. No visible control surfaces.

They descend. The object rotates on its axis, lines up with them and climbs. They end up face to face at barely half a mile, he at about 15,000 feet and the object at about 12,000. Then the object accelerates and vanishes. And here comes the data point that turns the anecdote into a case: according to Fravor, the Princeton picked it up again on radar at the patrol point, some sixty miles to the east, in under a minute.

TESTIMONYHIGH
Fravor told the committee that nothing we have can stop in midair and go off in the opposite direction, or, as in his case, come down from space, stay three hours and climb back up.
Cdr. David Fravor (ret.), USN 2023-07-26 House of Representatives, Washington, D.C.
Credibility

Beware the figure everyone repeats

You’ll have heard a thousand times that the object dropped from 80,000 to 20,000 feet in less than a second. That is a journalistic Frankenstein. Neither Fravor nor any official document gives that time figure. Fravor says it happened quickly, with no stopwatch. The leaked 2009 report gives altogether different altitudes. And the “less than a second” comes from an estimate by Petty Officer Kevin Day, deduced from the difference between two consecutive entries in a log, that is, from the system’s sampling rate, not from a measurement of acceleration.

When an impossible figure has three different sources saying three different things, the figure is a rumor with decimals, not a data point.

The 2009 “Executive Report”: the document that isn’t a document

In May 2018, journalist George Knapp published thirteen pages that have become the bible of the case. It contains the famous vocabulary of “AAV” (anomalous aerial vehicle), a description of the object as solid white, smooth, without edges, and an estimated length of about fourteen meters. It also contains a data point that enthusiasts tend to skip: the USS Louisville detected no anomalous sonar contact. In other words, the document cited to prove the case incidentally undercuts the fantasy of the mother-ship submarine.

EV-NIM-01Reliability: LOW
The so-called 2009 Executive Report: thirteen pages, no cover page, no date, no classification markings on the paper itself. Published by George Knapp (KLAS, Las Vegas) on May 18, 2018. Attributed to the work of contractors linked to the AATIP program. The Pentagon stated publicly that it could not confirm its authenticity. It has never been released as an official record through FOIA. Fravor does acknowledge, under oath, the 2009 investigation that produced it, and calls it the official unofficial report.

Look at the logical trap in all this, because it is beautiful. A document without a stamp is easy to disown and hard to deny. The State does not say it is false. It says it cannot confirm it. That sentence is a masterpiece: it commits no one, closes nothing, and leaves the citizen exactly where he was. In the hallway.

No Martians required: the conventional hypotheses

Now the part the congregation likes least and that is mandatory here at Broken UFO. There are mundane explanations on the table, and some are good.

  • The video doesn’t show what you think it shows. Mick West has spent years dissecting FLIR1 on Metabunk with an uncomfortably simple argument: the object barely moves on screen; what moves is the camera. The spectacular final “jump” to the left coincides with a zoom change of the pod from 1x to 2x. If you halve the size of the second half, the marvel evaporates.
  • The Tic Tac shape may be a thermal halo. In infrared, a distant, out-of-focus aircraft seen against the light produces an elongated blur larger than the aircraft itself. Goodbye wings. Goodbye control surfaces. Welcome, optics.
  • Fravor’s object may have been Kurth’s aircraft. It is the most provocative hypothesis in the matter and the one that has made the most noise. Kurth flatly rejects it: he says he had Fravor’s section on radar and that he was right above them. There is no data to close it.
  • Perception of size and distance over open sea is notoriously poor. No references, no scale, with two aircraft at hundreds of knots. That is the classic scenario where the human eye fails.
  • The patch of churned water can be anything from a school of fish or cetaceans to a breaking front over a shoal. No need to invoke anything exotic.
WHAT THE WITNESSES MAINTAIN
A solid object some 12 to 14 meters long, with no control surfaces, that reacts to the presence of the fighter, accelerates until it disappears and reappears on the Princeton’s radar at 60 miles in under a minute. Interference on the Super Hornet’s APG-73 radar.
VS
WHAT THE SKEPTICAL ANALYSIS MAINTAINS
The video shows a distant target whose apparent motion is explained by the movement and zoom change of the camera itself. The radar does not lock because the target is outside useful range, not because of interference. The reappearance at 60 miles is testimony with no record to support it.

And now the honest part: none of these hypotheses is proven either. There is no data to confirm them or rule them out. The debate between Fravor and West over whether the radar suffered interference or was simply out of range cannot be resolved, for a very unmysterious reason: the tape does not exist.

The real mystery: the disappearance of the data

Here is my case, and there is nothing extraterrestrial in it. On what happened to the Aegis records there are three incompatible versions, all from people with access:

  • Gary Voorhis, a systems technician on the Princeton, maintains that in the following hours a helicopter arrived with personnel in civilian clothes who took away the magnetic data tapes and refused to identify themselves.
  • David Fravor contradicts that version: he says the tapes were simply overwritten, as a matter of routine.
  • Sean Kirkpatrick, AARO’s first director, told The Guardian in March 2024 that nothing was kept because at that time the Department had no data retention policy.

Three different explanations. One and the same result: zero. And this, friends, is what costs me sleep. Because of the three, the one that should scare us most is the third, not the helicopter of the men in gray: the bureaucratic one, the one that says the U.S. Navy could have two weeks of anomalous tracks on an Aegis system and there wasn’t even a rule requiring anyone to keep them.

You don’t need a conspiracy to lose the truth. A wastebasket and a procedure nobody wrote are enough.

Add the kicker. The AARO Historical Record Report, the big 2024 historical report, does not mention the Nimitz even once. It doesn’t explain it, doesn’t rebut it, doesn’t cite it. And AARO’s case resolution reports page has an entry for GO FAST and none for this one. The most famous case of the modern history of the subject still has not a single official document analyzing it.

What I would do with this case file

Three things, and none of them involves believing in anything.

  • Request through FOIA the flight logs and the air wing reports for those dates. Not the magic tapes: the routine paperwork. If it doesn’t exist, that is information too.
  • Demand that AARO state in writing whether or not the case falls within its remit. A signed statement that it doesn’t apply is worth more than fifteen years of silence.
  • Publish the full video with its metadata and its chain of custody, not the clip that circulates. The raw material is the only thing that can settle a technical argument.

Meanwhile, we’ll stay where we are: with an excellent witness, an authenticated video that doesn’t prove what people think it proves, a leaked report nobody signs, and a hole the size of an aircraft carrier where the data should be.

Follow the thread: Fravor’s full statement, the profile of David Fravor, the case file on the three Navy videos and AATIP and our tracking of the 2026 NDAA.

OSINT – Source traceability

File completeness75/75
View breakdown
  • +20 Primary source linked
  • +5 Official domain
  • +15 Type: oficial
  • +10 Identified entity
  • +10 Source date
  • +5 Editorial notes
  • +5 Verification level assigned
  • +5 Documented corroboration
Source type Official
Entity / Origin U.S. Navy / Department of Defense; U.S. House of Representatives
Verification level V3 · Plausible
Timeline
Published source
Published on BUFO
Primary source www.congress.gov
OSINT editorial notes

Rated V3 and not V1 deliberately. What is verified at the official level is the authenticity of the video and the existence of the sworn statement, not the content of the event. The exact date of November 14 comes from the testimony and from the leaked 2009 report: the Department of Defense has said only November 2004. No coordinates are given because those in circulation appear in no primary source.

Sources
[01] Written statement of David Fravor to the House Oversight Committee, hearing of July 26, 2023
[03] ODNI, Preliminary Assessment: Unidentified Aerial Phenomena, June 25, 2021
[04] AARO, Report on the Historical Record of U.S. Government Involvement with Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena, Volume I (2024)
[05] Helene Cooper, Ralph Blumenthal and Leslie Kean, The New York Times, December 16, 2017
[06] KLAS Las Vegas, I-Team (George Knapp), publication of the Executive Report, May 18, 2018
[07] Metabunk, analysis threads on FLIR1 and the 2009 report (Mick West)
[08] Interview of Sean Kirkpatrick with Daniel Lavelle, The Guardian, March 22, 2024

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

Did the Pentagon confirm that the Tic Tac is extraterrestrial?
No. What it confirmed, in 2019 and 2020, is that the video is authentic and that the object remains categorized as unidentified. That means exactly what it says: they haven't identified it. Nothing more and nothing less.
Does the 2021 ODNI report address this case?
It does not mention it. The report names no individual case. Its dataset starts in November 2004, which allows one to assume the case is included, but assuming is not confirming.
What happened to the USS Princeton's radar recordings?
There are three incompatible versions: that unidentified personnel took them, that they were overwritten as routine, or that there was simply no obligation to keep them. None has been proven. All end the same way: there is no data.
Is there a conventional explanation for the video?
There is one serious technical hypothesis, defended mainly by Mick West: that the object is a distant, out-of-focus target and that the spectacular motion is produced by the movement and zoom change of the camera itself. It is not proven, but it has not been refuted either.
Is the 2009 Executive Report reliable?
It is a document with no cover page, no date and no classification markings, leaked in 2018. The Pentagon stated that it cannot confirm its authenticity, and it has never been released through official channels. Treating it as a Government document is a mistake.
Channel active
Newsletter
SEC:BUFO
Email newsletter

Get a briefing when something moves in the dark.

New case files, declassified documents, recommended reading and signs of anomalous activity. One email when it matters. Zero noise. Zero spam.

No mass mailings
Unsubscribe anytime
OSINT-friendly
Activate subscription
Alternate channel
Follow via RSS
Unit note

We don't sell your email, we don't run campaigns, we don't chase you with cookies. We only send what deserves a place in your archive.

Stable signal No ads One-click unsubscribe