Some trades teach you to distrust the sky better than any university chair, and technical editor at an aviation magazine is one of them. Philip Julian Klass spent thirty-four years at Aviation Week & Space Technology writing about radar, navigation systems and onboard electronics. He knew how machines fail, how pilots get things wrong and how a report gets written that nobody reads afterward.
With that baggage he entered the UFO debate in the mid-sixties and never left. He was the most persistent skeptic of his generation, the man who answered every book with another book and every letter with another letter. He was also, and it is best said from the start, a man capable of treating his adversaries as if they were suspects.
What he did: from avionics to saucers
The verifiable first. Klass was born in Des Moines in 1919, graduated in electrical engineering from Iowa State University in 1941 and worked for eleven years at General Electric, in aeronautical electronics. In 1952 he joined Aviation Week, where he rose to senior avionics editor and stayed until his retirement in 1986. He was, above all, a technical journalist with good contacts in industry and at the Pentagon.
His first foray into the subject was not skeptical in the classic sense. Following the 1965 New Hampshire sightings he proposed that many UFOs were atmospheric plasmas, relatives of ball lightning, formed near high-voltage power lines. He developed the idea in UFOs Identified (1968). It was a physical hypothesis without physical demonstration: no one had produced stable plasmas under the conditions it required. In his later books he set it aside.
He began by proposing an exotic explanation without proof. He spent the rest of his life reproaching others for doing the same.
Then came the phase for which he is remembered. In UFOs Explained (1974) he reviewed, one by one, some of the great American classics and sought a conventional explanation for each: radar malfunctions, planets, meteors, contradictions between witnesses, hoaxes. In 1976 he was among the founders of the Committee for the Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal (CSICOP), and from the late eighties he published his own bulletin, the Skeptics UFO Newsletter.
Abductions, Majestic 12 and Roswell
In the eighties and nineties he opened two new fronts. Against abductions he wrote UFO Abductions: A Dangerous Game (1988), in which he argued that regressive hypnosis fabricates memories and that the harm to the abductees themselves was real. Against the Majestic 12 documents he was among the first to point out anomalies of format and provenance. And in 1997 he devoted an entire book to Roswell, with a provocative thesis: the real cover-up was that of the UFO researchers themselves, who kept quiet about whatever weakened their case.
Ten thousand dollars and one condition
His most famous gesture was a public offer of ten thousand dollars to anyone who could prove they had been abducted by extraterrestrials, with a condition that said it all: the abduction had to be reported to the FBI, so that an agency with criminal jurisdiction would investigate, not a sympathetic ufologist. No one collected. His critics replied, with some justice, that the prize was designed never to be paid.
What he can be faulted for
This site does not hand out medals, not even to skeptics. The first criticism is the certainty with which Klass declared frauds. In several cases he did not limit himself to proposing a conventional explanation: he asserted that the witnesses were lying, with no more conclusive proof than what he demanded of believers. Accusing a specific person of a hoax is a claim of fact, and it demands the same rigor as accusing the sky of an extraterrestrial visit.
The second concerns conduct. Klass wrote to institutions and agencies to challenge those who defended UFOs. The best-documented case is that of James E. McDonald: Klass reported to the Office of Naval Research that the physicist had used a trip funded by an atmospheric research contract to interview witnesses in Australia in 1967. On the administrative point he was partly right. Informing on a colleague to the people who paid for his research was something else.
And the third concerns consistency. The man who began by selling plasmas without demonstration became the harshest guardian against hypotheses without demonstration. There is nothing wrong with changing your mind; what is wrong is not applying to yourself the yardstick you apply to others, and Klass rarely returned in public to his first book.
Why it matters
Klass matters because he showed that UFO skepticism could be done through fieldwork and documents, not only from a university chair, as Donald Menzel did. He read case files, called air traffic controllers, asked for the maintenance records of radars. When he was right, which was many times, he did it with the same papers his adversaries used, and that is what hurt them most.
He also matters as a warning. His rivalry with Stanton Friedman, which lasted decades, ended up as a duel of personas in which each needed the other to exist. Anyone looking for method in that fight will find it divided between both sides and buried under the same rhetoric. That is the part of Klass that this site does not want to imitate.
He died in Cherry Hill, New Jersey, in August 2005. He left a shelf of books that are still useful and a list of enemies that has not expired either. Both came out of the same typewriter.