Skip to content
Broken UFO Project BROKEN UFO
Archive / Person
DECEASED PER-001419 AMERICAN

James E. McDonald

Atmospheric physicist, University of Arizona

The atmospheric physicist from Arizona who wanted to bring UFOs into top-tier science. He re-interviewed hundreds of witnesses, took on the Condon report, and died in 1971 without seeing his cause win.

IDENTITY PER-001419
Born
1920-05-07 · Duluth, Minnesota, U.S.
Nationality
American
Education
PhD in physics, Iowa State University (1951)
Known for

Arguing before Congress (1968) and the AAAS (1969) that UFOs deserved a serious scientific program

Network connection level
0 connections
Start reading
Log 25/09/2026
Born 1920-05-07
Status DECEASED
Words 869

Some causes are defended with a megaphone and others with a field notebook. James Edward McDonald chose the notebook, and he filled it. An atmospheric physicist, a specialist in clouds and raindrops, he spent the last five years of his life crossing the United States and part of Australia to interview witnesses, read radar reports and put on record what others filed away without looking.

He was the most prestigious working scientist to stake his reputation on UFOs in the 1960s. He lost some of it, regained some of it, and died in June 1971 in circumstances that call for careful writing. His story is that of a good method applied to a hypothesis he could not prove.

PUBLICOREF: BUFO/PER-MCDONALD
NameJames Edward McDonald
BornMay 7, 1920, Duluth, Minnesota, U.S.
DiedJune 13, 1971, near Tucson, Arizona, U.S.
EducationPhD in physics, Iowa State University (1951)
InstitutionInstitute of Atmospheric Physics, University of Arizona
Specialtycloud physics and meteorology
Key appearancesHouse of Representatives symposium (July 29, 1968); AAAS symposium in Boston (December 1969)

What he did: the physics of clouds and of reports

The verifiable first, which is how you walk down a dark corridor. McDonald was born in Duluth, Minnesota, in 1920 and earned his doctorate in physics at Iowa State University in 1951. In the mid-1950s he joined the University of Arizona, where he worked at the Institute of Atmospheric Physics. He published on cloud microphysics, atmospheric electricity and artificial weather modification. He was no amateur: he was the kind of person who sees a mirage and can calculate the temperature inversion needed to produce it.

He had been interested in the subject for years, but in 1966 he took the step. He visited Project Blue Book at Wright-Patterson Air Force Base and came away convinced that the official investigation was superficial. From then on he devoted his free time, and a good part of the time that was not free, to re-interviewing witnesses of classic cases, until he had amassed hundreds of interviews. In April 1967 he gave the American Society of Newspaper Editors a lecture titled “Unidentified Flying Objects: Greatest Scientific Problem of Our Times”.

His thesis was not that UFOs were spacecraft. It was that nobody had looked at them seriously.

Congress, the AAAS and the least bad hypothesis

On July 29, 1968, he was one of the speakers at the symposium on unidentified flying objects held by the House Committee on Science and Astronautics, alongside J. Allen Hynek, Carl Sagan, Robert Hall, James Harder and Robert Baker. His statement argued that the problem deserved a serious scientific program and presented dozens of cases that he had reviewed himself, witness by witness.

In December 1969 he returned to the charge at the American Association for the Advancement of Science symposium in Boston, with a paper whose title summed up his opinion of the report by Edward Condon: “Science in Default: Twenty-Two Years of Inadequate UFO Investigations”. His personal conclusion was prudent in form and bold in substance: of all the available hypotheses, the extraterrestrial one seemed to him the least unsatisfactory.

What can be held against him

Here at Broken UFO we do not hand out medals, not even to someone who worked well. The first criticism concerns evidentiary weight. McDonald placed great trust in the consistency of witnesses: if a pilot, a radar operator and a policeman told the same story years later, he considered it a strong data point. It is, but not as strong as he believed. Memory gets contaminated, accounts spread from person to person, and the re-interview of a case from fifteen years earlier is not a new observation.

The second concerns temperature. His disputes with Donald Menzel and Philip J. Klass were bitter on both sides, and McDonald also resorted to discrediting his opponents. And the third is administrative: he used a trip to Australia funded in 1967 by the Office of Naval Research to interview UFO witnesses. Klass denounced it. It was a minor error turned into a weapon, but the error was his.

The end

In early 1971 he appeared before Congress to warn of the possible effects of commercial supersonic aircraft on the atmosphere, a subject on which he was on his own ground. A congressman brought up flying saucers to discredit him in front of everyone. What was under discussion was stratospheric physics; what the room remembered was the mockery.

That same year he attempted to take his own life and was left blind. On June 13, 1971, he died in the desert near Tucson. Those who knew him spoke of personal problems in addition to professional wear and tear. To attribute his death to a single cause, let alone to a conspiracy, is to do the myth a favor and him none.

ℹ
On his death
McDonald died by suicide in June 1971. No document links his death to the involvement of third parties, and speculation to that effect does not hold up. If this subject hits close to home, please seek help: in Spain, the 024 helpline for suicidal behavior operates around the clock.

Why it matters

McDonald matters because he showed that UFOs could be studied with method and under one’s own name, without hiding behind a pseudonym or an association of hobbyists. His papers are held at the University of Arizona and make up one of the best collections of witness re-interviews from the 1950s and 1960s. Ann Druffel reconstructed his story in Firestorm (2003).

And above all, he matters as a counterweight to Condon. Where the Colorado report summarized, McDonald detailed; where Condon concluded, he asked for another pass. He did not win. But every time someone demands serious investigation instead of filing away, they repeat his argument, often without knowing it.

His thesis was that the problem lay with the scientists who did not look, not with the witnesses. Half a century later, that case file remains open.

Sources
[01] Symposium on Unidentified Flying Objects, Committee on Science and Astronautics, U.S. House of Representatives, July 29, 1968.
[02] James E. McDonald, “Science in Default: Twenty-Two Years of Inadequate UFO Investigations”, AAAS symposium, Boston, December 1969.
[03] Ann Druffel, Firestorm: Dr. James E. McDonald's Fight for UFO Science, 2003.
[04] James E. McDonald, English Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org
Channel active
Newsletter
SEC:BUFO
Email newsletter

Get a briefing when something moves in the dark.

New case files, declassified documents, recommended reading and signs of anomalous activity. One email when it matters. Zero noise. Zero spam.

No mass mailings
Unsubscribe anytime
OSINT-friendly
Activate subscription
Alternate channel
Follow via RSS
Unit note

We don't sell your email, we don't run campaigns, we don't chase you with cookies. We only send what deserves a place in your archive.

Stable signal No ads One-click unsubscribe