Of the three who sat down on July 26, 2023, in room 2154 of the Rayburn building, the one who got the fewest headlines was Ryan Graves. Fair enough: he didn’t come to talk about non-human biologics or recovery programs. He came to talk about aviation safety and forms. And here at Broken UFO, forms are porn.
Graves was a Navy F/A-18 pilot for a decade, with deployments in Enduring Freedom and Inherent Resolve. By the time he testified he was executive director of Americans for Safe Aerospace, an organization he set up himself precisely because he couldn’t find anywhere to file the paperwork.
The three things he came to say
He organized it like a briefing, not a confession. Three points.
Graves told the subcommittee that, even as they met, there were UAP in our airspace, but that they are grossly underreported. He said these sightings are not rare or isolated: they are routine.
Second point: stigma. Graves describes it as an operational problem, not an emotional one. It silences commercial pilots, who fear professional consequences; it discourages witnesses; and (this part has some dry bite) it is made worse, he said, by recent government claims that question the credibility of eyewitness testimony. In other words: he is smacking down the line of argument of AARO without naming it.
Third point: classification. Verbatim from the record: since 2021, all UAP videos have been classified secret or higher. That fact, if you look at it twice, is funny to the point of laughter: the Pentagon declassified three videos in 2020 and immediately locked the door for the ones that followed.
The East Coast, 2014-2015, and a radar upgrade
The technical detail that holds up his whole account is this one, and it is in the record: between 2014 and 2015, off the East Coast, anyone who had upgraded their radar systems was seeing these objects. It is not a mystical sentence. It describes an instrumental bias: you change the sensor and a population of targets appears that wasn’t appearing before.
That allows two readings, and both are legitimate. One: there were things out there and we couldn’t see them. Two: the new radar generates artifacts or picks up mundane junk (balloons, drones, trash) that the old one filtered out. Graves says that at first they assumed the second (they took them to be radar errors) and that they changed their minds when they correlated the radar tracks with other onboard sensors, including infrared, and finally with visual identification.
When Congressman Jamie Raskin asks him what on earth they were seeing exactly, Graves gives the strangest and most useful description of the whole session: a dark gray or black cube inside a clear sphere, with the cube’s vertices touching the inside of the sphere. He adds that this went on for almost eight years and that, as far as he knows, it is still going on.
To Congressman Moskowitz he confirms something else: those spherical objects were observed at up to Mach 2. And Mach 2, for a sphere, is a rather unaerodynamic way to pass the time.
The 5%
Representative Nancy Mace asks him how many sightings he thinks go unreported. Graves clarifies that this is a personal estimate based on his conversations with pilots, and drops it: a reporting rate of around 5%. Mace repeats it out loud, because the figure deserves it: 95% goes unreported.
It is a statistic about professional fear rather than UFOs. And that one can be audited.
Careful with this number: Graves himself labels it a personal impression, not a study. Here we record it as what it is, an expert judgment without a sample. But it is an expert judgment that fits something objectively verifiable: until very recently, most aviation reporting systems had no box for this.
His proposal, by the way, is plumbing rather than opening the hangar: a central repository that collects military and civilian reports, and a two-way communication loop so that whoever files the report gets an answer. Deadly boring. And probably the only thing in the whole hearing that can be carried out without believing in anything.
One last note, because it amused me and because it says a lot: Graves stated that he has become aware of conversations with commercial aviators who received cease-and-desist orders. Congresswoman Luna asked him whether that means companies put their reputation ahead of passenger safety. He answered that it appears so. A very short answer. Very elegant. Very unreassuring.
Complete it with the testimony of David Fravor from the same day and with the record of the session.
OSINT – Source traceability
Graves runs an advocacy organization on the subject, which introduces agenda bias. Flagged medium. The 5% estimate is explicitly his own personal impression, not a study, and the record says so.